Literacy5 min read

What to do when your child hates reading

Reading is the thing every other subject is made of. Here is how to rebuild a reader who has decided books are not for them.

Written by a practising Australian teacher·SubjectMate

There's a particular kind of grief in watching a kid who loved books at 5 decide at 9 that reading isn't for them.

It also has consequences. Reading isn't a subject. It's the thing every other subject is made of.

A struggling reader in Year 5 becomes a struggling science student in Year 8. Not because of the science. Because of the textbook.

Nobody hates reading

They hate what it currently costs them.

For a kid who decodes slowly, a page is work. By the time they get to the bottom of it, the effort of getting the words off the page has used up everything they needed to enjoy the story.

They're not being difficult. They're being efficient. Something that costs a lot and gives back nothing gets dropped.

Researchers have a name for what happens next. Stanovich called it the Matthew effect, after the line about the rich getting richer. Kids who read easily read more, which makes them better readers, which makes them read more again. Kids who find it hard read less, and the gap opens a little wider every year.

Which is why this is worth taking seriously now rather than hoping they grow out of it.

So the question is never "how do I make my child read more?"

It's "what is reading costing them, and can we make it cost less?"

The 3 usual causes

It's still hard mechanically. Decoding isn't automatic yet, so all the effort goes into the words and there's none left for the meaning. This one needs targeted help, not more reading time.

The books are wrong. A kid pushed through a novel they've no interest in learns that reading is a chore. Most common cause. Easiest to fix.

It's become a battleground. Once reading happens under supervision with a timer and a log to sign, it's homework. Nobody chooses homework.

Graphic novels count

Say it plainly, because a lot of parents don't believe it.

Graphic novels count. So do comics, joke books, footy statistics, game manuals, magazine articles about sharks, and the same book for the 11th time.

Volume and enjoyment are what drive reading development, and there's a serious body of research behind that.

Mol and Bus (2011) pulled together studies of print exposure from infancy to early adulthood. How much a child reads explained around 30% of the differences in oral language skills by secondary school, and about 12% in primary.

Look at the gap between those two numbers. Reading volume matters more as your child gets older, not less.

Cunningham and Stanovich spent 10 years following the same children and found that how much they read uniquely predicted their vocabulary, general knowledge and spelling. Not their IQ. How much they read.

So: a kid who reads 300 pages of something you think is trivial is building fluency, vocabulary and stamina. A kid who reads 20 pages of an approved classic under duress is building resentment.

There's no ladder where comics are the bottom rung. There's reading and not reading.

Keep reading aloud longer than you think

Most families stop the moment their child can read alone. That's exactly backwards.

Your child's listening comprehension runs years ahead of their reading comprehension.

Reading aloud lets them meet stories, vocabulary and ideas their decoding can't reach yet. And it keeps books and pleasure connected during the years when their own reading is still hard work.

10 minutes at night, well into primary school and beyond, does more than any reading log ever printed.

Things that actually work

Let them abandon books. You do it constantly. Making a kid finish something they hate teaches exactly one lesson.

Let them reread. Rereading isn't lazy. It's how fluency gets built.

Audiobooks aren't cheating. They build vocabulary and story sense, and plenty of reluctant readers find their way in through their ears.

Get the level right. A book should be comfortable, not aspirational. If they're stumbling on more than a few words a page, that book is work.

Take the audience away. Reading to a dog, a sibling, or an empty room is much less exposing than reading to a parent who winces at every mistake.

Let them see you read. Not a lecture about reading. Just you, on a couch, with a book, enjoying it.

When to get help

If your child's avoiding reading and it's still mechanically hard for them in Year 4 or beyond, that's worth looking at properly rather than waiting out.

Talk to their teacher, and ask specifically about decoding and fluency. Not about attitude.

The kids who come back are nearly always the ones where somebody worked out what reading was costing them, and then made it cost less.

Common questions

Do graphic novels count as real reading?
Yes. Volume and enjoyment drive reading development. A kid who reads 300 pages of something you think is trivial is building fluency, vocabulary and stamina. There's no ladder where comics are the bottom rung.
Should I keep reading aloud after my child can read alone?
Yes, for years longer than most families do. Listening comprehension runs well ahead of reading comprehension, so reading aloud gives your child access to vocabulary and ideas their own decoding can't reach yet.

References

  1. Mol, S. E., and Bus, A. G. (2011). To read or not to read: a meta-analysis of print exposure from infancy to early adulthood. Psychological Bulletin, 137(2), 267–296. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021890
  2. Cunningham, A. E., and Stanovich, K. E. (1991). Tracking the unique effects of print exposure in children: associations with vocabulary, general knowledge, and spelling. Journal of Educational Psychology, 83(2), 264–274. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.83.2.264
  3. Cunningham, A. E., and Stanovich, K. E. (1997). Early reading acquisition and its relation to reading experience and ability 10 years later. Developmental Psychology, 33(6), 934–945. https://doi.org/10.1037/0012-1649.33.6.934
  4. Stanovich, K. E. (1986). Matthew effects in reading: some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21(4), 360–407. https://doi.org/10.1598/RRQ.21.4.1

Support that guides rather than tells

SubjectMate asks your child what they know first, then guides them to the answer. Built by a teacher, available every school night.

See how it works →

More for parents

What your child’s school report actually means5 min read Why rereading notes doesn’t work6 min read